Managing a homeowners association (HOA) presents unique challenges due to the myriad of personalities, rules, and shared community interests involved.

With any homeowner focused on investing both financially and emotionally into their properties, complaints are bound to arise.

This guide will explore the most prevalent HOA homeowner complaints and offer effective strategies for addressing and resolving them, aiming for a harmonious community living experience.

Understanding the Landscape of HOA Complaints

A homeowners association is designed to preserve the value of properties and maintain a certain standard of community living.

However, with regulations come disputes.

Some frequent sources of complaints stem from the following:

  • Perceived excessive fees
  • Perceived inconsistencies in rule enforcement (selective enforcement)
  • Restrictions on aesthetics or property modifications
  • Disagreements over common area maintenance

There are many other possible reasons that board members might receive an HOA complaint, but these are some of the most common. We'll get into them in more detail later on.

The Impact of Unresolved Complaints

Unaddressed grievances can have cascading consequences for an homeowners association community.

Not only can they erode trust between homeowners and the HOA board, but they can also lead to legal disputes, decreased property values, and a general atmosphere of discontent.

Furthermore, persistent issues can make it challenging to attract new homeowners or keep current residents satisfied.

In essence, the ripple effects of unresolved complaints can compromise the very essence of community living, making resolution not just important, but imperative.

Top 9 HOA Complaints and How a Management Company Can Address Them

Let's now take a closer look at the most common homeowners association complaints and what a community manager, property manager, board members, and others on the HOA management company team can do to resolve these disputes.

most common reasons for an hoa complaint and how a community manager or board manager can resolve the dispute

1) Excessive HOA Fees

Homeowners associations are established with the promise of maintaining and even enhancing the community's quality of living. This often comes with a price tag in the form of HOA fees.

While these fees are essential for community upkeep, excessive or unexpected hikes can lead to discontent.

Several factors can influence HOA fees:

  • Unexpected repairs: Emergencies or unforeseen infrastructure needs can drive up costs.
  • Amenity upgrades: Enhancements like a new pool, gym, or clubhouse can require a higher budget.
  • Operational costs: Increases in utility prices, insurance rates, or management fees can inadvertently affect the HOA dues.

Addressing concerns over excessive fees requires transparency and proactive communication. Here are some tips for achieving that:

  • Transparent budgeting: Providing a clear breakdown of costs allows homeowners to understand where their money is being directed. Monthly or quarterly financial reports, or even an annual report, can be a valuable tool.
  • Regular financial audits: Conducting periodic audits ensures that funds are being utilized correctly and can also identify areas of potential savings.
  • Open forums: Hosting regular meetings where residents can discuss the budget, understand the necessity for fees, and voice concerns can foster understanding and trust within the community.

2) Inconsistent Rule Enforcement

Rules and regulations are the backbone of any HOA, aiming to maintain a harmonious community environment.

However, when these rules are inconsistently enforced, it can breed confusion, frustration, and allegations of favoritism. Inconsistent rule enforcement can undermine trust, fuel conflicts, and diminish rule effectiveness.

Homeowners may begin to doubt the integrity of the HOA board or its management team, question the rationale behind the rules, or feel unfairly targeted and believe others are being given preferential treatment.

Known as selective enforcement, this practice, when done intentionally, is also illegal. For that reason, it's important to ensure consistent rule enforcement and address related concerns with care and clarity. Here's how:

  • Clear rule documentation: HOA rules should be written clearly and comprehensively, reducing ambiguity. An accessible and updated rulebook should be provided to all residents.
  • Regular training for staff: Ensure that those responsible for rule enforcement are well-versed in the regulations and the reasons behind them. This includes security staff, community managers, and other HOA personnel.
  • Open communication: When a rule is enforced, communicating the reason behind the decision can reduce misunderstandings. Similarly, if exceptions are made, the rationale should be explained to the community.

3) Overreaching Aesthetic Controls

A community's visual appeal is often protected and enhanced by HOA guidelines.

However, strict or seemingly arbitrary aesthetic controls can sometimes feel stifling to residents, leading them to believe their personal freedoms and expressions are being unduly limited.

Striking the right balance is crucial.

While every homeowner wishes to imprint their personality on their home, it's essential to ensure that individual choices don't disrupt the overall aesthetic harmony of the community. After all, a consistent and pleasing aesthetic can maintain or even increase property values within the community. It can also prevent potential disputes between neighbors over clashing aesthetic choices.

Some of these seemingly aesthetic-based controls are also rooted in safety concerns as well, even if the complaining homeowner isn't aware of it. That's why communication is so important.

In general, addressing concerns over aesthetic controls requires tact and open dialogue:

  • Periodic restriction re-evaluations: Times change, and so do aesthetic sensibilities. Periodic reviews ensure that rules remain relevant and don't feel outdated or overly restrictive.
  • Feedback loops: Engage community members in discussions about aesthetic guidelines. Their feedback can provide invaluable insights into what feels reasonable and what feels excessive.
  • Visual examples: Provide clear visual guidelines or examples of acceptable aesthetic choices. This can help homeowners understand the boundaries and make informed decisions.

4) Holiday Decorations

Holiday decorations bring seasonal complaints. They're a great way for residents to express their celebrations and traditions, but they're one of the most common issues, as they sometimes clash with the HOA's rules and guidelines.

Additionally, without some boundaries, decorations might become excessive, linger too long, or even pose safety hazards. In diverse communities, it's important that these decorations respect all cultural and religious sensitivities as well.

When handling an HOA complaint about holiday decorations or setting rules, keep these tips in mind:

  • Duration limits: Define a window during which decorations can be put up and a deadline by which they should be taken down.
  • Acceptable decorations: Offer guidelines that outline the range of acceptable decor, ensuring safety and respect for all community members.
  • Communication: Well before the holiday season, communicate any guidelines to homeowners. This gives them ample time to plan their decorations within the set rules.

5) Noise Complaints

Noise complaints are a headache for everyone: homeowners, tenants, HOA members, landlords, property managers, and everything in between.

What's routine for one household might be disruptive for another, especially when it comes to noise.

Here are some of the most common sources of noise complaints:

  • Loud music and TVs
  • Parties
  • Pets
  • Home improvements
  • Community facilities like gyms and pools

Addressing noise complaints effectively can help maintain peace within the community. Here are some tips for addressing a noise complaint swiftly and proactively:

  • Clear noise guidelines: Define "quiet hours" during which certain noise levels should not be exceeded. This can apply to both household activities and the use of community facilities.
  • Soundproofing suggestions: Offer homeowners tips or recommendations for soundproofing their homes, helping to reduce noise transmission.
  • Open communication channels: Encourage residents to communicate directly with neighbors about minor noise issues before escalating to the HOA, fostering a sense of community understanding. You might offer a community phone book for this.
  • Mediation: For persistent issues, consider mediation sessions where both parties can voice their concerns and work towards a resolution.

6) Parking Disputes

Parking issues are one of the most common disputes in HOA communities. As residents vie for limited spaces or become frustrated with perceived infractions, tensions can arise, making it essential for HOAs to have clear and fair parking rules in place.

These disputes are usually caused by there being a limited number of available parking spots (compared to how many vehicles are in the community), inappropriate parking in unauthorized areas, guests, and extended vehicle storage for abandoned or rarely used vehicles.

To mitigate parking-related disputes, a proactive approach is key. Implement these tips:

  • Clear parking guidelines: Clearly define where residents can park, how visitor parking operates, and any restrictions like vehicle size or type.
  • Regular communication: Send reminders of parking rules periodically, especially during events or peak seasons when parking may be tight.
  • Flexible solutions: Consider introducing a permit system, rotational parking, or even exploring off-site parking solutions for overflow.
  • Dispute resolution mechanism: Establish a clear process for residents to report parking violations or to appeal against any penalties they might receive. This ensures fairness and transparency.

7) Pet Policy Issues

Pets bring joy and companionship to many households. Yet, in an HOA community, pet ownership can lead to disputes over noise, damage, or simply the type and number of pets allowed. Some people might also have allergies, phobias, or concerns about property damage.

Finding a balance that respects both pet owners and non-pet owners is essential.

Here are some strategies for resolving and preventing these HOA complaints:

  • Clear pet policies: Clearly define what types of pets are allowed, any breed or size restrictions, and the responsibilities of pet owners regarding noise and waste management.
  • Designated pet areas: If possible, create designated areas for pets to play or relieve themselves. This can reduce damage to common areas and provide a space for pets to be pets.
  • Education and resources: Provide resources on pet training, behavior management, and responsible pet ownership. Educated pet owners are often more responsible.

8) Challenges with Home Modifications Approval

For many homeowners, modifying their property to suit their tastes, needs, or lifestyle is a natural part of homeownership.

However, within an HOA community, such changes often require approval to ensure consistency and maintain community aesthetics. This process can sometimes lead to disagreements or perceived inefficiencies.

Typically, the complaints that come along with individual homeowners seeking to personalize their spaces are caused by delayed approvals, a lack of transparency about criteria, perceived unfairness and selective enforcement, and restrictive or outdated guidelines.

Addressing these challenges requires a structured and transparent approach:

  • Clear modification guidelines: Provide homeowners with detailed guidelines outlining what is permissible and what requires approval. The clearer the guidelines, the fewer misunderstandings.
  • Defined timeline: Set and communicate a specific timeframe within which homeowners can expect a decision on their modification request.
  • Reasons for decisions: If a request is denied, always provide a clear reason, helping homeowners understand the decision-making process.
  • Periodic guidelines updates: Periodically review and update modification guidelines to ensure they remain relevant and in line with current design and building trends.

9) Unprofessional Behavior by HOA Board Members

Sometimes the HOA complaint comes from an issue within.

The HOA board plays a pivotal role in managing and leading the community. Thus, when board members exhibit unprofessional behavior, it can erode trust, foster negativity, and hinder effective community management.

Many of the aforementioned causes for HOA complaints come from bias, favoritism, a lack of transparency, poor communication, and conflicts of interest. When concerned homeowners see this, they might file a report about the HOA itself, rather than their bylaws.

This is where being proactive is crucial so that you can restore trust, ensure effective leadership, and mitigate any potential risks of dealing with a judge or lawsuits dealing with discrimination or other law-related issues.

Prevent such a complaint and stay on top of your HOA office by taking these measures:

  • Clear code of conduct: Establish a defined code of conduct for board members, outlining expected behaviors, communication norms, and consequences for violations.
  • Regular training: Offer regular training sessions on leadership, communication, and conflict resolution to equip board members with the necessary skills.
  • Open channels of communication: Ensure that residents have a clear and accessible way to communicate concerns or grievances related to board behavior.
  • Third-party mediation: In cases of serious disputes or recurring issues, consider involving a neutral third-party mediator to facilitate resolution.

When in doubt, always consult an attorney for guidance.

Bottom Line

While complaints are an inevitable part of managing diverse communities, the manner in which they are addressed can significantly impact the overall atmosphere and resident satisfaction.

Ensuring that issues are handled efficiently, transparently, and empathetically not only resolves individual disputes but strengthens community bonds.

how to handle hoa complaints

These are common tips for how to handle not only the complaints mentioned in this blog post but also any others:

  • Actively listen to your residents
  • Maintain thorough records of every complaint, action, and resolution
  • Promptly acknowledge complaints
  • Create clear governing documents for the HOA
  • Encourage residents to voice their concerns, and offer open channels of communication
  • Turn to third-party mediation when necessary
  • Send reminders and educate your residents about community rules and policies
  • Be consistent about fines and other consequences for any breach in policy

It's all about the approach, and with the right strategies, HOAs can create environments where every resident feels valued and heard.