North Carolina is prone to natural disasters like tropical storms and hurricanes. Landlords often know this and will buy landlord's insurance to protect themselves and their properties from damage. However, what about the tenants?

As a landlord, you know you need insurance to protect yourself from the North Carolina storms you might encounter. However, renters insurance is something your tenants should get. You can require this in the lease agreement, which means all tenants will have to buy it.

It's important for you to learn as much as you can about North Carolina renters insurance coverage options. You want to understand why it's necessary, when to require it, and how it might help you in case of an accident.

Today, you will learn about renters insurance in North Carolina. We'll take you through what it is, what it protects, and why you should make tenants get it. Let's dive in!

What Is North Carolina Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance is very similar to homeowners insurance because it covers unexpected events that might arise. These are usually called covered perils or losses. In fact, the insurance will protect people with personal property coverage, liability coverage, and ALE (additional living expenses).

Usually, North Carolina renters insurance is broad enough to help in many situations. However, the tenant will need appropriate coverage to cover anything that might go wrong.

Though the cheapest renters insurance companies will help them comply with the lease, it might not be enough to cover their personal belongings or offer liability coverage to prevent them from being sued and paying out of pocket.

Let's learn more about the process for buying renters insurance in North Carolina.

Average Cost of Renters Insurance in North Carolina Per Year

What's the average cost of renters insurance in North Carolina? The average annual price is $162, which equals $14 per month, according to NerdWallet. For comparison, the national average is only $148.

North Carolina uses a credit-based insurance score to set the insurance rates you pay. This is similar to a traditional credit score, but it's not the same.

Those who want the cheapest renters insurance in North Carolina will likely have to shop around to get the best deal. Likewise, they may have a higher deductible to lower the cost or might have to get less personal property coverage to make it fit in their budgets.

People with poor credit might pay an average annual cost of $231 for renters insurance in North Carolina.

How Much Does North Carolina's Renters Insurance Cost (Based on Popular Cities)?

Likewise, the average cost of renters insurance in North Carolina depends on where the property sits in the state. For example, Charlotte residents will pay about $163/year, but Fayetteville is about $244.

There are ways to get the cheapest renters insurance in North Carolina if tenants know how to shop around. Here's a list of the average prices based on the city, according to NerdWallet.

  • Winston-Salem - $163/year
  • Wilmington - $268/year
  • Wake Forest - $162/year
  • Salisbury - $155/year
  • Raleigh - $159/year
  • Moorseville - $158/year
  • Monroe - $161/year
  • Matthews - $162/year
  • Lexington - $157/year
  • Jacksonville - $239/year
  • High Point - $163/year
  • Greenville - $197/year
  • Greensboro - $163/year
  • Fayetteville - $244/year
  • Charlotte - $163/year
  • Burlington - $163/year
  • Asheville - $137/year

Is Renters Insurance Required in North Carolina?

Many people ask: Is renters insurance required in North Carolina? The state doesn't have a law that requires a renters insurance policy. However, landlords can mandate it in their leases before tenants are allowed to live in the building.

It's generally wise for tenants to get renters insurance in North Carolina. However, landlords often wonder how they'll know if they did so. You can ask for proof of insurance before the tenant moves in and before leases are renewed.

Overall, the best renters insurance typically covers the tenant's personal belongings and pays when they're liable for damages or injuries on the property. Therefore, it's wise for you to require North Carolina renters insurance from your tenants to protect them after a covered event.

When you decide to put renters insurance in the lease, make sure the tenant knows they will have to include you on the policy as an interested party. That means you're notified of a cancellation or change. In a sense, tenants can't simply buy renters insurance in North Carolina to get approved and then drop it later.

What Does Renters Insurance Cover in North Carolina?

People often wonder: What will renters insurance cover in North Carolina? It protects the tenant's personal belongings if they are damaged or stolen. Likewise, renters insurance covers injuries and property damage the tenant accidentally caused to others. However, North Carolina is prone to hurricanes and tropical storms, which might not be covered. You'll learn about that later.

Here are the coverages that most North Carolina renters insurance companies offer:

Personal Property Coverage

Even the cheapest renters insurance coverage will offer personal property coverage. This will cover the tenant's personal belongings after being stolen, destroyed, or damaged. Things like clothing, furniture, electronics, artwork, and jewelry are included here but only up to the coverage limits.

Additional Living Expenses

Suppose the tenant cannot live in the rented house because of a problem covered under the North Carolina renters insurance policy. In that case, the company will reimburse them for additional living expenses. This can include things like restaurant meals, hotel bills, and other essentials.

Liability Insurance

Liability coverage will cover any property damage or injuries the tenant causes to others. For example, if their dog bit the neighbor, the liability insurance pays for the medical bills. Likewise, it will cover court costs, legal defense costs, and settlement payments for those living in North Carolina.

What Does Renters Insurance in North Carolina NOT Cover?

Standard renters insurance in North Carolina generally covers wind damage, but it won't protect from flooding. For example, a hurricane blows the roof off of the apartment building. This caused rain to ruin the tenant's furniture. Typically, cheap renters insurance policies will replace the lost items minus the deductible.

However, if that hurricane caused a flood on the street and water got into the tenant's unit, they probably wouldn't be covered under the North Carolina renters insurance policy unless it included flood insurance.

Generally, North Carolina renters insurance companies will charge different deductibles for windstorm damage if the building is near the coast. Sometimes, companies call these endorsements or riders. They are like separate policies that offer more protection, though it often costs more, as well.

How to Choose the Right Policy

Tenants often focus on low renters insurance rates, so they could sacrifice coverage options to help them save money. Instead, they should be focusing on the renters insurance companies that will offer the protection they need. Let's learn how to choose a policy correctly:

  • Location - Renters insurance prices are based on the property's location, so the cost might be higher or lower, depending on where they live. Large cities might have more theft, making the price skyrocket. However, rural areas may also see a higher premium because emergency services can't get on-site as quickly.
  • Coverage - Typically, tenants have many companies available to help them buy renters insurance. Plus, they can customize the policy to meet their needs for extra personal property coverage or add-ons for flooding and hurricanes.
  • Deductible Amount - A deductible is how much the tenant will pay out of pocket before the policy kicks in to cover the rest. Getting a high deductible lowers the premium. However, they will likely pay more after a covered event. In some cases, the cost of repairs is less than the deductible, so they're left footing the entire bill.

Available Discounts in North Carolina

Every company has renters insurance discounts, but they will vary significantly. Therefore, it's best to check with each one to see how to save money.

Even the cheapest renters insurance company will have a couple of discounts, and the most common ones you'll see include:

  • Bundling discounts
  • No-claims discount
  • Automatic payments discount
  • Protective device discount (smoke detectors, fire alarms, burglar alarms, and more)
  • Retired senior discount
  • Pay-in-full discount
  • Paperless discount
  • Secure/gated community discounts

How Does a Renters Insurance Policy Protect the Landlord or Property Manager?

Many landlords wonder why they should require renters insurance and how it protects them. This is a valid question because some tenants will ask you this, and you should have a good answer for them. Here are the six reasons why you should make sure your renters are insured:

  • Easier to Take Pets - Landlords almost always turn away tenants with pets because of the hassles it brings. You picture upset neighbors with bites and scratches. However, renters insurance with pet liability will protect from those things.
  • Find Better Tenants - You can indirectly screen tenants by requiring renters insurance. If they're willing to carry it, they're likely responsible and will take care of the property.
  • Covers Relocation - In some situations, North Carolina landlords will have to cover relocation costs for the tenants if the property is deemed unlivable. Renters insurance will reimburse tenants for those costs, so you won't have to.
  • Less Personal Liability - Renters insurance can be helpful if a guest gets injured on-site. The tenant is sued instead of the landlord. However, be aware that landlords are typically only liable if the property is structurally unsound.
  • Protects a Tenant's Personal Property - Most tenants don't realize that landlord's insurance only covers the landlord's items and building structures. Therefore, landlords might be held responsible for certain damages if the tenant doesn't have renters insurance to protect their artwork, clothing, furniture, keepsakes, and electronics.

Top 5 Best Renters Insurance Companies in North Carolina

It's time to focus on the best renters insurance providers in North Carolina. Here are the options available:

1. State Farm

State Farm

State Farm is the best cheap renters insurance company available. It has great customer support and has been around for many decades. Therefore, it offers financial stability and strength.

Those who prefer the personal touch will like that they can call and get quotes or file claims. However, there are many online tools to help people get assistance quickly.

Overall, there aren't many ways to get lower renters insurance rates. State Farm offers limited discounts (multi-policy and home alert protection options). Likewise, some people say the coverage isn't the best.



USAA could be the best renters insurance company for military veterans and their families. It's been around for a long time, so it offers financial stability and great customer satisfaction. The only caveat here is that it's only available to those with a military background.

Still, USAA is available in all states, and the standard policy includes unique options for coverage, such as identity theft coverage, earthquake, and flood damage. Renters who want a quote can get one through the website, and it also provides calculators for debt management, savings, and insurance. They'll need to download an app but can then manage their policies anywhere.

3. Travelers


If tenants want the best renters insurance in North Carolina, they might wish to check out Travelers. It offers unique coverages, such as refrigerated property coverage and decreasing deductibles. Likewise, tenants will typically get great customer service and various discounts to help them lower their premiums.

Though it's not the cheapest for renters insurance, many people like it because of the coverage options it provides.

4. Allstate


When tenants need cheap renters insurance in North Carolina, they might check out Allstate. It was one of the least expensive options and has decent renters insurance coverage. Plus, tenants can get unique discounts depending on their location and your building.

Those who prefer online tools will enjoy the mobile app and website. Tenants can take care of everything without having to make a call or go somewhere. However, it doesn't have the best customer service possible, so people who like speaking to a live person might have problems.

5. Nationwide


People who want the best cheap renters insurance in North Carolina might want to check out Nationwide. On average, it has low prices and costs roughly $15/month, which is cheaper than the average cost of renters insurance coverage in the state.

Nationwide offers various protections apart from the standard ones. For example, tenants can get identity theft protection, water backup coverage, and full replacement cost coverage. Likewise, tenants have access to various discounts, including bundling auto and renters insurance to save money.

However, Nationwide only offers average customer service compared to other brands. Still, the NAIC (National Association of Insurance Commissioners) claims that it doesn't get as many customer complaints as other companies, so that's a good thing!

What Is DoorLoop?

Understanding the benefits of North Carolina renters insurance for yourself and your tenants is a great first step. Now, you know to include it in the lease. However, it's your job to stay organized, knowing who paid, who is current with the renters insurance payments, and much more.

You can use DoorLoop to help you tackle it all. This all-in-one property management software serves landlords of all types. You might stick with commercial or residential properties solely or might have a mixed-used portfolio. Regardless, DoorLoop can assist. It offers these benefits:

  • Rent collection on autopilot
  • Management of the full rental portfolio
  • Offering tenants an online tenant portal
  • Management of all maintenance requests to avoid calls and texts from tenants all the time
  • Website creation (free and customized) for new tenants to apply and for landlords to market vacancies with Zillow or Trulia
  • Management of accounting

Does this sound enticing? Many landlords find they need help to keep things organized, and DoorLoop will make it that much easier. You can schedule a demo today and learn more about how this software works!

Why Work with DoorLoop

Tenants don't think about buying renters insurance policies unless it's a requirement in their North Carolina rental property. You can mandate that in the lease, which means they'll comply. However, it might be helpful to tell them how it works, what it does, what it will cover, and what companies are ideal.

DoorLoop can help if you require tenants to get a renters insurance policy. They can apply for it directly in the tenant portal or on the tenant application. It's powered by Lemonade or SURE, depending on what state you live in. Likewise, they can submit their own renters insurance if they prefer to go with another company.

See how DoorLoop can assist with renters insurance today!  

David is the co-founder & CMO of DoorLoop, a best-selling author, legal CLE speaker, and real estate investor. When he's not hanging with his three children, he's writing articles here!

Legal Disclaimer

The information on this website is from public sources, for informational purposes only and not intended for legal or accounting advice. DoorLoop does not guarantee its accuracy and is not liable for any damages or inaccuracies.