.svg){kind=icon}
Chasing tenants for renters' insurance is a time-consuming headache. You send emails, leave voicemails, and track everything on a spreadsheet, all while hoping a policy doesn't lapse and leave you exposed to liability without the right financial protection.
DoorLoop solves this.
Our property management software is built to automate compliance. You can require and track renters' insurance policies directly within DoorLoop, eliminating spreadsheets and follow-up emails for good. Standardize onboarding with a move-in checklist and keep proof on file from day one.
This guide shows you exactly how DoorLoop makes this process effortless. We'll also provide a renters insurance review of the top providers on the market that you can recommend to your tenants.
Why Every Landlord Should Require Renter's Insurance
Requiring renters' insurance is one of the most thoughtful decisions for your properties. It creates a critical safety net that protects your investment in the event of a covered occurrence, and it clearly separates your responsibilities from those of your tenant.
Your own homeowners' insurance does not cover a tenant's items, which is a common misconception.
Here’s why it’s a non-negotiable:
- It Protects You From Tenant Negligence. Imagine a tenant accidentally starts a kitchen fire, causing damage far beyond their security deposit. A standard renters insurance policy includes personal liability coverage, which helps cover repair costs. This also applies if a guest trips and sues for medical payments, preventing you from being pulled into a costly insurance claim.
- It Covers Unexpected Events. What if a burst pipe upstairs floods their unit, or a break-in and subsequent vandalism damage their personal belongings? Renters insurance helps tenants recover without paying out of pocket, ensuring a covered loss doesn't prevent them from paying rent.
- It Reduces Your Own Claims. When a tenant's policy responds first, it reduces the likelihood of claims against your landlord insurance policy. Staying claim-free helps keep your own insurance rates down.
Key Policy Details to Look For
Not all policies are created equal. To ensure you’re adequately protected, here are the non-negotiable details to look for in a tenant’s renters insurance coverage:
- Sufficient Personal Property Coverage. This protects the tenant’s possessions. They should choose an amount of coverage that is enough to replace everything they own, from furniture to electronics.
- Clear Coverage Limits. Every policy has a maximum payout for different categories. Tenants should understand their limits for things like jewelry or other valuable items and consider add-ons if needed.
- Replacement Cost Coverage. This is a crucial feature that pays to replace old items with new ones, rather than their depreciated value. Also, confirm the policy includes loss of use, which provides for additional living expenses if the rental property becomes uninhabitable.
- You Listed as an "Additional Insured." This is critical. It ensures you are notified if the policy is canceled or changed.
Best Renters Insurance Companies for Tenants
Now that you know how to automate the management side with DoorLoop, here are the top-rated providers you can confidently recommend to your tenants.
Top Choice for Speed & Integration: Sure and Lemonade
We specifically chose Sure and Lemonade as our integrated partners for a reason: they offer an incredibly fast and simple application process, instant online quotes, and excellent coverage that protects both tenants and landlords.
For tenants who need affordable renters insurance quickly, this is the fastest path from lease-signing to full compliance, right from their DoorLoop portal.
Best for Bundling with Other Policies: State Farm and Geico
Many tenants can get a discount by bundling renters' insurance with an existing auto insurance policy. State Farm and Geico are two of the most popular providers for these bundles. DoorLoop makes it easy for tenants to upload these external policies, allowing you to track their compliance seamlessly.
Best for Military Members: USAA
According to the J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Home Insurance Study, USAA consistently ranks high. They offer excellent rates and tailored service for active-duty military members and veterans.
Best for Customizable Coverage: Allstate and Progressive
Allstate and Progressive are solid, well-known options that offer a wide range of coverage choices. For tenants with specific needs or who want to fine-tune their policy details, it's another great company to recommend.
Our Methodology
To identify the best renters insurance companies, our methodology focused on the factors that matter most to busy property managers and their tenants. We analyzed each provider based on a balanced set of criteria to ensure they offer real value and reliability.
Here’s what we looked for:
- Ease of Use: How fast can a tenant get a quote and secure a policy? We prioritized companies with simple online applications and instant approvals, because a faster process means faster compliance for you.
- Company Reputation: We analyzed third-party data on financial stability and overall customer satisfaction, including results from sources like the annual J.D. Power study. A provider must be reliable when it’s time to pay a claim.
- Coverage & Flexibility: We evaluated the quality of a standard policy, looking for comprehensive protection against common risks. We also favored companies that offer flexible coverage options and useful endorsements for things like valuable items or water backup.
- Overall Value: We compared the average cost of renters insurance from each provider to ensure they offer competitive and transparent pricing. Our goal is to recommend companies that provide excellent protection without being a burden on your tenants.
What if a Tenant Already Has Insurance?
Many tenants get a discount by bundling renters' insurance with their car insurance. So, what happens when they want to use their own policy?
DoorLoop is designed for exactly this scenario.
If a tenant has an existing policy from another provider, they simply upload the documents directly to their tenant portal. There's no need for them to switch or for you to do any manual data entry.
The moment they upload it, DoorLoop takes over. Our software logs the provider, policy details, and expiration date. You get the same automated tracking and expiration reminders as you would with an integrated policy.
Either way, you have perfect visibility of your entire portfolio from a single dashboard. It's total compliance with total flexibility.
DoorLoop: Your All-in-One Renter's management Tool
DoorLoop is for managing every aspect of your properties, including risk and compliance. We built a feature to handle the entire renter's insurance process, so you can stop worrying and get back to work.
How It Works in Two Simple Steps:
- You Require It: In DoorLoop, you simply mark that a tenant is required to have renter's insurance. Consider sharing the requirement with a landlord introduction letter to set expectations clearly.
- They Comply Instantly: Tenants get an alert in their online portal (powered by tenant management software) with two easy options:
- Option A: Purchase a Policy in Minutes. They can buy a policy directly through our integrated partners, Sure and Lemonade. The policy is then automatically logged and tracked in DoorLoop—no data entry for you. For onboarding, tie this to leasing and rental applications.
- Option B: Upload Their Own Policy. If they already have insurance from another provider, they can upload their documents in seconds.If questions arise, point residents to the legal basics in landlord-tenant rights.
Your dashboard gives you a real-time view of who is covered and who isn’t—use reports to stay audit-ready. The software also automatically reminds tenants before a policy expires via communication tools, eliminating the need for manual follow-up (and you can check the status from anywhere with mobile apps).
The Smart Choice: It’s About the Software, Not Just the Policy
While there are many great insurance providers, the policy itself doesn't solve your administrative headache. The real challenge for property managers is the endless task of tracking and verification.
Making the smart choice means adopting software that does the heavy lifting for you.
DoorLoop gives you and your tenants the flexibility to use any provider, while guaranteeing you have the control and automation you need on the backend.
Stop chasing tenants. Start managing smarter.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does renters insurance cover?
A policy typically covers the tenant's personal property from risks like fire, theft, and some types of water damage. It does not, however, cover damage from rising water—a separate flood insurance policy is needed for that. Many policies also offer additional coverage for items such as water backup from a sump pump or identity theft.
What is the average renters' insurance cost?
The average cost of renters' insurance varies by location, from California to Florida. The average premium is typically between $15 and $30 per month. The final policy cost depends on factors like the coverage amount, the chosen deductible, and the tenant's claims history.
How can my tenant find the cheapest renters' insurance?
The best way to find a good price is to get a renters' insurance quote from multiple companies. They should compare not just the price, but what is covered. Sometimes a slightly more expensive policy offers significantly more protection, such as coverage for pet damage or a lower deductible in case they need to file claims.
What happens if a tenant needs to make a renters' insurance claim?
If an incident occurs, the tenant will contact their insurance company to start the renters' insurance claim process. They will need to document the damage and work with an adjuster to get reimbursed for their losses. This is entirely separate from a landlord’s home insurance or life insurance. They can typically pay for their policy with a credit card.
.avif)
.svg)
.svg)
