Stessa vs Avail: Which Property Management Platform is Right for Your Rental Business in 2025?

Managing rental properties efficiently comes down to choosing the right tools for your specific needs. Two platforms consistently top landlord conversations: Stessa and Avail. While both serve property owners, they take fundamentally different approaches to solving your management challenges.

Stessa positions itself as an accounting-first solution, designed specifically for real estate investors who prioritize financial tracking and tax preparation. Avail offers a complete property management solution covering everything from tenant screening to maintenance requests. Understanding these core differences will help you choose the platform that matches your management style and portfolio goals.

Choose the Right Property Management Solution

Property management software has evolved beyond simple rent collection tools. Today’s platforms either specialize deeply in specific areas or attempt to cover the entire landlord workflow. Stessa and Avail represent these two distinct philosophies.

Stessa focuses primarily on financial tracking and accounting for real estate investors. Built by investors for investors, it automates the tedious work of categorizing expenses, tracking rental property income, and preparing tax reports. The platform connects with over 15,000 financial institutions to automatically import and categorize transactions.

Avail provides comprehensive property management tools including tenant screening and lease management. Originally founded in 2012 for independent landlords, it covers the complete rental cycle from marketing vacant units to collecting rent and managing maintenance requests.

This detailed comparison will help you determine which platform best fits your rental property management style, whether you’re focused on investment performance or day-to-day operations.

What Makes These Platforms Unique?

Stessa – Financial-First Property Management

Stessa operates as accounting software designed specifically for rental property owners and real estate investors. The platform’s strength lies in its sophisticated approach to financial management, treating your properties as investment assets rather than just rental units.

The automated income and expense tracking connects directly with your bank accounts, credit cards, and financial institutions. Every transaction gets automatically categorized using machine learning algorithms that understand real estate expenses. This eliminates hours of manual data entry and reduces categorization errors that can cost you money at tax time.

Tax-ready financial reporting including Schedule E forms sets Stessa apart from basic property management tools. The platform generates IRS-compliant reports with one click, automatically organizing your income and expenses into proper tax categories. For residential real estate investors managing multiple properties, this feature alone can save hundreds of dollars in accounting fees.

The free Essentials plan includes unlimited properties and basic features, making it accessible for investors just starting their portfolios. Advanced features like detailed performance metrics and priority support come with the Pro plan at $20 monthly.

Stessa’s Cash Management Account offers competitive APY rates while integrating seamlessly with your property financials. All ACH payments through this account are free, reducing your operational costs compared to traditional banking.

Avail – Complete Landlord-Tenant Solution

Avail functions as an end-to-end property management platform for independent landlords who want to handle their own properties efficiently. Rather than focusing solely on financials, Avail covers every aspect of the landlord-tenant relationship.

Tenant screening, lease creation, and rental listings on multiple sites streamline the vacancy-to-occupied process. The platform posts your rental listings automatically to major sites like Apartments.com, Zillow, and Realtor.com, maximizing your property’s exposure without manual posting to each platform.

Maintenance request management and tenant communication tools keep operations running smoothly. Tenants can submit requests with photos, track progress, and communicate directly through the platform. This creates clear documentation trails and reduces the back-and-forth emails that eat up your time.

The free Unlimited plan includes basic features like rental listing capabilities and simple rent collection. Premium features including waived ACH fees, advanced reporting, and expedited payments require the Plus plan at $9 per unit monthly.

Integration with Realtor.com through Move’s acquisition provides enhanced marketing reach and lead generation capabilities that standalone platforms can’t match.

Stessa vs Avail: Feature Comparison

Financial Management

Stessa: Advanced accounting features dominate this platform. Automated categorization assigns every transaction to appropriate tax categories, while portfolio analytics track cash flow, ROI, and property appreciation across your entire portfolio. The banking integration pulls data from over 15,000 institutions automatically.

Avail: Basic income tracking and expense management handle essential financial tasks but lack sophistication. The platform tracks rental income and basic expenses but doesn’t provide the detailed analytics or automated categorization that serious investors need.

Tax Preparation:

• Stessa: Generates detailed tax reports and Schedule E forms automatically, with all income and expenses properly categorized for IRS compliance
• Avail: Simple financial summaries without advanced tax preparation tools - you’ll still need separate accounting software or professional help

Tenant Management

Stessa: Basic rent collection through Stessa Rent Pay with no ACH fees when using their Cash Management Account. Online rent collection works reliably but lacks advanced tenant management features.

Avail: Comprehensive tenant screening including background checks, credit reports, and eviction history through TransUnion. The screening fees are typically paid by applicants, not landlords.

Communication and Operations:

• Stessa: Limited tenant communication features - primarily focused on payment reminders and basic messaging
• Avail: Full tenant portal where renters can pay rent, submit maintenance requests, access lease agreements, and communicate with landlords

Property Marketing

Stessa: No rental listing capabilities - this platform focuses entirely on financial management rather than vacancy marketing.

Avail: Posts listings to multiple rental sites automatically, including Apartments.com, Zillow, Trulia, and HotPads. Built-in marketing tools create property websites and manage inquiries from prospective tenants.

What Property Owners Say

Real user feedback reveals how these platforms perform in daily operations. Property owners consistently highlight different strengths based on their primary needs.

Stessa users praise automated accounting and tax preparation features above all else. “Stessa streamlines my entire property investment financial process, saving me dozens of hours at tax time. The integration with my bank accounts is seamless,” reports one investor managing a 12-unit portfolio.

The financial reporting capabilities receive particular praise from residential real estate investors who previously struggled with manual expense tracking. Users frequently mention how the platform’s automated categorization catches deductions they would have missed, often paying for itself through improved tax compliance.

Avail users appreciate comprehensive tenant management and screening tools that simplify day-to-day operations. “Avail made finding, screening, and signing with tenants a breeze. The tenant portal is straightforward, and maintenance tracking is a real time-saver for me as a part-time landlord,” shares an independent landlord.

The customer support quality differs notably between platforms. Avail provides phone support alongside email and chat, while Stessa focuses on email and chat support with extensive self-service resources.

Pricing and Value Comparison

Understanding the true cost requires looking beyond base monthly fees to include transaction costs and scaling implications.

Stessa Pricing Structure:

• Free Essentials Plan: Unlimited properties, core accounting features, basic reporting
• Pro Plan: $20 monthly flat fee for advanced features, priority support, enhanced analytics
• No per-unit charges: Same cost whether you manage 1 property or 100
• ACH Fees: Free when using Stessa Cash Management Account, standard fees with external banks

Avail Pricing Structure:

• Free Unlimited Plan: Basic rent collection, maintenance requests, tenant communication
• Plus Plan: $9 per unit monthly for premium features, waived bank fees, advanced reporting
• Screening Fees: Typically paid by tenants ($55-60 for complete background checks)
• Transaction Fees: Reduced on paid plans, tenant-paid on free plan

Cost Analysis by Portfolio Size:

The pricing models create different value propositions. For landlords with single properties or small portfolios, Avail’s per-unit pricing offers better value. However, Stessa’s flat-rate structure becomes increasingly attractive as portfolio size grows.

Consider the total cost of ownership beyond base subscription fees. Stessa’s automated tax preparation can save $200-500 annually in accounting fees. Avail’s comprehensive screening tools can reduce vacancy time and bad tenant costs, potentially saving thousands per year.

Which Platform is Right for You?

Your choice between these platforms should align with your primary management challenges and growth goals.

Choose Stessa if you want:

Advanced financial tracking and automated accounting for your rental properties. Stessa excels when you’re treating properties as investment assets requiring detailed performance analysis. The platform’s strength in organizing income and expenses makes it invaluable for serious investors.

Tax-ready reports and Schedule E preparation that eliminate manual tax work. If you’re spending hours organizing receipts and categorizing expenses each tax season, Stessa’s automation will save significant time and potentially uncover missed deductions.

Integration with banking services and portfolio analytics to optimize investment performance. The Cash Management Account combined with detailed reporting helps you understand which properties perform best and where to focus improvement efforts.

Focus on investment performance and return optimization rather than day-to-day tenant management. Stessa works best for investors who use separate services for tenant screening and marketing but want sophisticated financial tracking.

Choose Avail if you want:

Complete property management including tenant screening and leasing in one platform. Avail shines when you’re handling all aspects of property management yourself and want streamlined workflows from vacancy to rent collection.

Marketing tools to advertise vacancies and find tenants efficiently. The automatic posting to multiple rental sites and lead management features can significantly reduce vacancy time compared to manual marketing efforts.

Maintenance request management and tenant communication that keeps operations organized. The tenant portal and maintenance tracking prevent issues from falling through cracks while maintaining professional communication standards.

All-in-one platform for day-to-day landlord operations without requiring multiple tools. Avail works best for hands-on landlords who want everything in one place rather than managing multiple specialized platforms.

Both Stessa and Avail serve important roles in the property management ecosystem, but they excel in different areas. Your choice should align with whether you prioritize sophisticated financial management or comprehensive operational tools.

For property managers and landlords seeking a platform that combines the best of both worlds—advanced financial tracking with comprehensive property management features—DoorLoop offers a complete solution. Built for speed and designed for growth-minded teams, DoorLoop provides the automation and insights you need to scale your portfolio efficiently. Ready to see how modern property management software can streamline your operations? Book a demo to discover how DoorLoop can help you manage more properties with less effort.

‍